Commonwealth Centre for Connected Learning
  • Home
  • About
    • Who We Are
    • What We Do
  • Conferences
    • Past Conferences
  • Projects
    • The GenZ Project
    • DEL4ALL
      • Expert Interviews
      • Webinars/Workshops
    • Webinars
      • Emerging Technologies Webinars
      • Digital Literacy Lab for Educators
  • Resources
    • Teaching Resources
    • Small Island Developing States & Tourism Webinar
    • Social Justice Education
    • Digital Enhanced Learning
  • Blog
  • Contact
  • Search
  • Menu Menu

Education, Media, and Technology in a Post-Truth World: An Analysis

Critical Literacy, Digital literacy, Journalism, post-truth

‘Introduction to Media, Technology and Education in a Post-truth Society: From Fake News, Datafication and Mass Surveillance to the Death of Trust’ was launched on the 8th July 2021. This collection of essays is edited by 3CL director Alex Grech.

The essays revolve around this ongoing information crisis in the fields of Education, Media and Technology. Their authors seek to deconstruct and analyse the term ‘post-truth’ in their relative fields as well as find possible ways forward.

Questions formulated in the introduction are:

‘Will Big Tech ever take responsibility for the harm and lies caused by the misinformation they permit to spread on their platforms? Will there ever be new media models coded for the common good and which are free from native advertising?’[1]

The following premises served as the basis for this book:

  • The post-truth problem is real.
  • The post-truth problem is nuanced and needs a critical approach.
  • Unbiased and current knowledge is needed to inform workable solutions that resist the excesses of the post-truth society. [2]

The Role of Education in a Post-Truth Era

What is the role of truth? How can we differ from many truths?

Covid-19 has brought about a play of political information leading to the invention of the term ‘infodemic.’ We can only be optimistic when there are more calls to ‘establish, celebrate, protect and reform large-scale authorities’; those at the helm who are responsible for building and engaging with information.[4] Yet, in education a broader struggle exists: Do educators have the tools to help students become wise navigators of the future information environment? Or are they scaremongering agents who seek to protect students from a space that could warp minds?[5]

Critical literacy instruction could be the tool that helps students ‘treat the root cause’ of the issue; thus serving as the fulcrum of a safe information space.[6]

Open innovation and open governance could possibly bridge the gap between an ever-evolving technology and  regulatory governance models playing catch-up. The move from closed values to open values may provide the tools for more trust, transparency, and autonomy.[7]

Is Journalism Dead in a World of Apocryphal Truth?

In a world where democracy finds itself undermined and threatened in a consistent manner, how do we go about saving journalism?

The first online portal to be attacked for spreading fake news was none other than Wikipedia. However, years and several ‘robust mechanisms’ later, it has come to safeguard its readers more than any other social media out there. The way the power of Wikipedia was controlled could serve as a lesson to other social media platforms. [8]

‘A gimmicky reaction’ to Trump’s election motto resulted in the name of an organisation called Make Media Great Again. This organisation aims to improve the quality of media through annotations, based on possible suggestions and labelled notes attributed to words, sentences, or paragraphs. [9]

Manipulated and fake images have also contributed negatively to the post-truth society in which we live. It is important to develop visual literacy and a critical approach to visuality as well as bolster ethical standards when it comes to creating visual narratives. This also applies when injecting storytelling elements in news writing.[10]

Negotiating With Technology in an Era of Debatable Truth

At this point, Blockchain is still in its early stages and thus, it is hard to assume what effects it will have and how it will evolve as it spreads. It could also take a completely different form to the one initially predicted. If it requires the service of all users, coming from all walks of life, then one cause for hope is that it leads to Labour and Capital collaborating together. [11]

Though it is does not provide a long-term solution to the issue of fake and multiple untruths, Blockchain could be the ideal tool for recording the two sides to that story.[12] Data ledger Technologies offer Self-sovereign Identity, Self-sovereign Data together with transparent and verifiable data and processing. This is the best we could hope for when it comes to channelling trust on the Web.[13]

Could Scientific Truth be the Key Solution?

When dealing with post-truths on social media platforms, thinking like scientists could be the answer. We could trust the ‘authority of the method rather than the authority of particular people or their social position.’ [14] This aligns with Yuval Noah Harari’s thoughts that ‘…the scientific community has been our most reliable source of knowledge for centuries.’ [15] Checking for empirical evidence when believing a claim is crucial. That should also be the case when making a claim.

 

 

[1] Grech, A. (2021)  Introduction (pg 6) in Media, technology and education in a post-truth society: From fake news, datafication and mass surveillance to the death of trust. United Kingdom: Emerald Publishing.

 

[2] Grech, A. (2021) pg 4,  ‘Introduction’ in Media, technology and education in a post-truth society: From fake news, datafication and mass surveillance to the death of trust. United Kingdom: Emerald Publishing.

 

[3] Portelli J.P. and Oladi S. Post-Truth Society: Toward a Dialogical Understanding of Truth (pg 25) in Media, technology and education in a post-truth society: From fake news, datafication and mass surveillance to the death of trust.

 

[4] Alexander, B. Macroauthorities and Microliteracies: The New Terrain (pg 36) in Media, technology and education in a post-truth society: From fake news, datafication and mass surveillance to the death of trust.

 

[5] Alexander,B. Macroauthorities and Microliteracies: The New Tearrain ( pg 36) “”.

 

[6] Pauncefort, E. Critical Literacy is at the Heart of the Answer (pg 89) in Media, technology and education in a post-truth society: From fake news, datafication and mass surveillance to the death of trust.

 

[7] Balser, W. F. et al. Societal Reorientation via Programmable trust: A Case for Piloting (pg 106) in Media, technology and education in a post-truth society: From fake news, datafication and mass surveillance to the death of trust.

 

[8] Sant, T. How can Wikipedia Save us all? Assuming Good Faith from all Points (pg 142) in Media, technology and education in a post-truth society: From fake news, datafication and mass surveillance to the death of trust.

 

[9] Brave, R. Public rebuttal, Reflection and responsibility. Or an Inconvenient Answer to Fake News (pg 153) in Media, technology and education in a post-truth society: From fake news, datafication and mass surveillance to the death of trust.

 

[10] Topolska, A. Reflections on the Visual Truth and War Photography (pg 200) in Media, technology and education in a post-truth society: From fake news, datafication and mass surveillance to the death of trust.

 

[11] Basu, D. and Gabbay, M. Karl Marx and the Blockchain (pg 238) in Media, technology and education in a post-truth society: From fake news, datafication and mass surveillance to the death of trust.

 

[12] Ellul,J. Grech,A. and Pace, G.J. Two Sides to Every Story. The Truth, Post-truth, and Blockchain Truth in Media, technology and education in a post-truth society: From fake news, datafication and mass surveillance to the death of trust.

 

[13] Third, A, and Domingue, J. Decentralised Verification Technologies and the Web in Media, technology and education in a post-truth society: From fake news, datafication and mass surveillance to the death of trust.

 

[14] Smolenski, N. How Do We Know What Is True? (pg 275) In Media, technology and education in a post-truth society: From fake news, datafication and mass surveillance to the death of trust.

 

[15] Harari, Y.N. (2018) Post-Truth in 21 Lessons for the 21st Century United Kingdom: Vintage: Penguin Random House.

 

October 19, 2021/by Carla Gatt
Tags: critical thinking, disinformation, post-truth society, technology
Share this entry
  • Share on Facebook
  • Share on Twitter
  • Share on WhatsApp
  • Share on Pinterest
  • Share on LinkedIn
  • Share on Reddit
  • Share by Mail
https://www.3cl.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/09/AdobeStock_144639643_Preview.jpeg 664 1000 Carla Gatt https://www.3cl.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/10/logo.png Carla Gatt2021-10-19 12:19:452021-10-19 12:19:45Education, Media, and Technology in a Post-Truth World: An Analysis
You might also like
Kenneth Cukier on Big Data Post-truth Conference Speaker Kenneth Cukier on the Big Data Revolution
Reading Between the Blurred Lines in a Post-Truth Era
How AI, ML and digital games can change student learning success DEL4ALL Thematic Workshop on AI, ML and digital games in education
Women and Girls in Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics (STEM)
DEL4ALL interview series Affordable technologies for the public good
small states Defining Small Island Developing States
Michael Casey - speaker, educator, author, media entrepreneur Michael J. Casey to Keynote at Post-truth Conference
Herman Grech, Ruben Brave, John Domingue, 3CL Post-truth Conference, 2019 3CL Malta Conference on Post-truth Society: Day One Recap

Newsletter

Subscribe for updates on connected learning, digital literacy and 3CL events.

See our Privacy & Data Policy.

Recent Articles

  • Will AI apps replace artists?
  • Will ChatGPT destroy education or resuscitate it?
  • Young People & Information: It’s Complicated Conference 2022
  • 3CL participates in Education Training on Virtual Reality applications
  • Partnerships for SIDS Webinar: Renewable Energy Sources and Water Management

Topics

  • 3CL News (45)
  • Blockchain (12)
  • Conferences (12)
  • Connected Learning (6)
  • Covid-19 (5)
  • Critical Literacy (1)
  • DEL4ALL (7)
  • Digital literacy (14)
  • Digital Literacy Lab for Educators (7)
  • Education & Tech Literacy (1)
  • EU (4)
  • higher education (3)
  • islands and small states (1)
  • Journalism (1)
  • Lifelong Learning (7)
  • Media and Technology (1)
  • OER (9)
  • post-Covid (3)
  • post-truth (4)
  • Projects (1)
  • Quality Education (2)
  • Research (2)
  • Small States Centre of Excellence (3)
  • STEM (2)
  • Uncategorized (3)
  • VRTeacher (1)
  • Webinar (15)

Twitter

3CLMT @3clmt
3 Keys to Evolving as a Lifelong Learner - Engaging in a process of learning, unlearning, and relearning puts educators on a path to continuous improvement https://t.co/M7AOfqExdH #lifelonglearning

- 13 hours ago

h J R
3CLMT @3clmt
Zarya of the Dawn: US Copyright Office Affirms Limits on #Copyright of #AI Outputs https://t.co/tUixbk0S6I #creativeindustries #creativecommons

- 1 day ago

h J R

Newsletter

Subscribe for updates on connected learning, digital literacy and 3CL events.

See our Privacy & Data Policy.

Check out our latest Newsletter here.

© Copyright 2016-2023 Commonwealth Centre for Connected Learning.
All site content, except where otherwise noted, is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license. This is in line with Open Access Publication Guidelines. Commonwealth Centre for Connected Learning: 89, Archbishop Street, Valletta, VLT 1448, Malta info@3CL.org

Privacy, Cookie & Data Protection Policy · Disclaimer · Terms & Conditions

Reading Between the Blurred Lines in a Post-Truth EraSIDS Webinar on Renewable EnergyPartnerships for SIDS Webinar: Renewable Energy Sources and Water Managemen...
Scroll to top