Understanding Australia’s Recent Social Media Minimum Age Act
Australia’s recent legislative development, the Online Safety Amendment (Social Media Minimum Age) Act 2024, has sparked a significant debate about how governments can regulate the digital world, particularly in relation to young people. The Act aims to prohibit individuals under the age of 16 from accessing social media platforms however there are still major questions about implementation. This bold move, scheduled to take effect by December 2025, raises essential questions about privacy, data security, and how technology can effectively prevent young people from circumventing age restrictions.
Legislation Overview
The Online Safety Amendment (Social Media Minimum Age) Act marks a pioneering step in Australia’s approach to controlling the influence of social media on young people. Currently little is known about how this ban will work in practice other than that the legislation mandates that social media platforms implement “reasonable steps” to verify users’ ages and restrict individuals under the age of 16 from creating accounts.
The specific platforms subject to this regulation have not yet been determined; however, the government has indicated that platforms such as TikTok, Facebook, Snapchat, Reddit, Instagram, and X are likely to fall within its scope. Certain categories of platforms will be exempt from the age restriction such as messaging applications like WhatsApp and Facebook Messenger Kids, gaming platforms, and services offering educational content, such as YouTube.
Meaningful Age Verification
Currently, meaningful age verification does occur in the case of for example financial services however these laws are standardised across countries making them more easily enforceable. However, challenges abound, especially when it comes to balancing these systems with user privacy and data protection. The Australian government has as such stated that it will not require individuals to submit passports or state identification.
With the use of identification documents now ruled out, supporters of the bill say platforms may look to biometric forms of age assurance, such as facial scanning, to fulfil the requirements of the legislation. This however also brings privacy concerns of its own. Furthermore whilst this software has some success with caucasian faces, the same cannot be said for other races.
Another option that has been bandied about is the introduction of an AI that trawls one’s profile to spot evidence of one’s age. However, similarly, this type of policy has privacy concerns and somewhat plays into Musk and his adherents’ criticism that this is a backdoor for governmental control of internet access.
Alas, for now, this is all speculation; an age assurance trial has begun and will likely clarify how the government plans to actually implement this act. As a result, the practical implications of the law remain unclear. If the government opts for more stringent checks this will involve some reduction in user privacy and will likely inadvertently block legitimate content or users who fall into grey areas of the law, impacting freedom of expression online. On the other hand, if the measures are too loose, the Aussie government will struggle to get citizens to comply.
Challenges and Potential Workarounds for Youths
One of the central challenges of the Online Safety Amendment (Social Media Minimum Age) Act is how easily tech-savvy youths might circumvent the age restrictions. While the legislation’s intent is clear, history shows that when young people encounter restrictions, they often find ways around them. As schools and parents began imposing restrictions on platforms, young people found ways to shift to less-monitored platforms, even going so far as to use Google Docs to communicate and collaborate. This adaptability illustrates young people’s ingenuity when it comes to staying connected, often circumventing regulations and accessing the content they seek.
This dynamic highlights the difficulty governments face when attempting to restrict access to global platforms. Even if Australia successfully blocks social media access for young people, there’s a real concern that youths might migrate to less-regulated, underground social platforms or use VPNs to bypass geographical restrictions. This is already a common practice in China, where Western sites are accessed despite being banned through what is known as the Great Firewall.
A Positive Step for Mental Health
On the flip side, the Online Safety Amendment (Social Media Minimum Age) Act serves as a response to the growing mental health crisis among Gen Z that social media have exacerbated. Social media platforms are often blamed for contributing to issues like anxiety, depression, and body image problems among young people. This policy sends a clear message that social media is a powerful tool that can significantly affect youth development. By imposing stricter age limitations, the government is encouraging a shift toward healthier offline engagement and development for children.
Even if the law doesn’t fully prevent young people from accessing social media, it creates substantial barriers that may discourage younger users from easily engaging with these platforms. The law also encourages parents, educators, and communities to foster healthier online habits and prioritise face-to-face interactions, which could have long-term benefits for youth mental health.
Broader Implications
Australia’s Online Safety Amendment (Social Media Minimum Age) Act could serve as a global model for regulating social media use among youth. Other countries may follow suit and introduce similar legislation, creating a ripple effect in the global conversation on the safety of young people online. The legislation also highlights the inherent complexities of regulating global platforms that operate across borders. Ensuring compliance without infringing on privacy and individual freedoms will be a delicate balancing act for any nation attempting to implement similar laws.
The Act does not ban all forms of social media and as such encourages social media companies to provide alternatives to standard platforms, such as creating age-appropriate versions for younger users. This could involve limiting access to certain features, and ensuring that platforms remain safe for those under 16 while complying with the legal framework. If such platforms are appealing, young people and parents might naturally migrate to such platforms even if they could use workarounds to access the full version of applications.
Conclusion
Australia’s attempt to regulate social media access for those under 16 represents a landmark moment in digital governance. The success of this policy will depend on effective implementation and finding the right balance between protecting young people and respecting their privacy. Whether the Online Safety Amendment (Social Media Minimum Age) Act becomes a model for other countries or a cautionary tale remains to be seen. However, its bold approach to safeguarding youth from the potential dangers of social media makes it a topic worth watching closely in the coming years.
Independent MP Andrew Wilkie highlighted how “The voices of children and young people have been conspicuously missing from most of the debate and commentary.” Young people are important stakeholders in this policy and their input is not only valuable in terms of seeing whether this policy will be popular. Due to the many ways to circumvent such regulations, this policy can only truly work with goodwill and popular support from young people, parents and institutions. Malta, where the 3CL is based, announced they are closely watching Australia and considering a similar move. As such, we have conducted a vox pop to see what students based in Malta think of this legislation.


